Retiree Faces Legal Twist After Incident with Walmart Drone in Florida

Walmart store entrance with blue bollards at dusk.
HALLANDALE BEACH, FLORIDA, USA-October 15, 2015: Walmart 24 hour supercenter in Hallandale Beach Florida. Walmart is the largest retailer in the USA Based in Arkansas

It is not quite like swatting away a fly. A Florida retiree realizes this as he faces legal ramifications for shooting down a delivery drone. When the Walmart delivery drone flew over his house, he took a 9 mm and shot it down. Dennis Winn is accused of criminal mischief and public discharge of a firearm.

Retired Fire Captain Takes Aim at Walmart Drone

In an unexpected turn of events, Dennis Winn, a 72-year-old retiree and former New Jersey fire captain, was arrested after shooting at a Walmart delivery drone in Clermont, Florida. The incident occurred during a mock delivery campaign by a Walmart crew in the neighborhood, raising concerns about the intersection of new technology and personal privacy.

Winn admitted to firing a 9mm pistol at the drone, citing previous encounters with drones he believed were spying on him. This action revealed a bullet hole in the drone’s payload, which could cost up to $2,500. The incident has raised awareness about the growing presence of commercial drones in residential areas, as well as the challenges they pose.

Legal Ramifications and Plea Deal

The consequences of Winn’s actions were swift and severe. He was initially charged with shooting at an aircraft (a second-degree felony), criminal mischief causing over $1,000 in damage (a third-degree felony), and discharge of a firearm in public or on residential property (a misdemeanor). These charges highlight the gravity with which law enforcement handles incidents involving drones, which are classified as aircraft by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA).

“A bullet hole was discovered in the payload the drone was carrying” – the police

However, in a recent development, Winn reached a plea agreement that could result in the felony and misdemeanor charges being dismissed. As part of this agreement, he will participate in a pretrial intervention program, which is similar to probation and can last up to a year. Winn has also been ordered to pay $5,000 in restitution to DroneUp Delivery, the damaged drone’s owner.

Walmart’s Drone Delivery Program and Public Reaction

This incident has raised awareness of Walmart’s ongoing efforts to expand its drone delivery services. Since 2021, the retail giant has been testing drone delivery, with over 30,000 successful deliveries to date. Walmart started offering drone deliveries in Florida in 2022 as part of a partnership with DroneUp, a commercial drone services company.

“Over the last two years trialing drone delivery, we’ve completed over 20,000 safe deliveries” – Walmart

While Walmart views drone delivery as an innovative way to serve customers, the Winn incident highlights some residents’ concerns about privacy and the presence of drones in their communities. The company has stated that it intends to “influence the expansion of drone technology and enable other businesses to explore its benefits,” but it is clear that public education and community engagement will be critical as this technology gains popularity.

Legal and Safety Considerations

The Winn case serves as a reminder of the serious legal consequences of interfering with drone operations. Due to the risk of harm, federal law makes it illegal to shoot down drones, even if they are trespassing. Drones are classified as aircraft by the FAA, so shooting at them is a federal offense punishable by fines and imprisonment.

Concerns about safety extend beyond shooting at a drone. Firing bullets into the air is inherently dangerous because they can cause injuries or deaths when they come down unexpectedly. Law enforcement and legal experts stress the importance of understanding and following aviation laws for community safety.

Sources: